It’s just the smart thing to do

Diagram illustrating the flow of money invested in mutual funds.
Graphic from Rakuten Securities.

Recently a desperate arms race has broken out in Japan, triggered by the opening up and promotion of iDeCo accounts to most of the population, and escalated by a race to lock in customers.

We have all benefited.

Because of this arms race between the institutional giants, the range of mutual funds in ​Japan is better than ever. Right now, unless you are a US citizen*, the best way to invest in Japan is probably through mutual funds.

* If you are a US citizen you need to stick to individual Japanese companies or invest in the US using existing accounts. Alternatively you can open an account with Interactive Brokers.

I used to buy US ETFs, which seemed like a reasonable option at the time. Now, it is clearly a suboptimal one.

So what is so good about mutual funds?

Well, a mutual fund is a pool of money gathered from investors to buy assets. See more information here.

The main advantages of mutual funds in Japan are low fees and convenience.

Highlighted quote saying: "Most people should be able to use mutual funds to make simple, low-cost portfolios for themselves. Invest regularly over the long term and you should do pretty well for yourself."

You can now get extremely cheap mutual funds with no purchase fees, no redemption fees (look for ノーロード ‘no load’ funds) and very low annual costs on pretty much every major trading platform.

You can also buy them in yen, which means no need to incur fees to change your money into dollars.

You can buy them any time (the orders are processed once a day), and in lots of 1 yen (as opposed to a stock or ETF, which will have a unit cost several thousand times that).

When you buy a fund, you can usually choose whether it will pay out dividends (受取型) or reinvest them (再投資型).

With many brokers, it is relatively easy to set up regular investments (積立) where the broker will take money from your money account or bank account to buy a set investment each month. This means you can set your account up and then forget about it. Come back in a couple of decades and find yourself much better off.

Comparison with US ETFs

​Compare this to buying US ETFs (like the Vanguard ones recommended by US authors or bloggers):

What kind of mutual funds are available?

Pretty much anything you want. I recommend no-load, index-based mutual funds with low annual fees.

Most brokers will have a mutual fund (投資信託 toushi shintaku) section with tools to search and screen. I usually screen for ノーロード funds then look for the type I want (all-world equities, Japanese bonds, developed world equities, emerging market bonds, etc.).

One thing to keep in mind is that most ‘world’ funds will be ex-Japan (they don’t include Japanese assets). As Japan makes up about 10% of the world stock market, if you want to mirror the world exactly you will need to have about 10% of your portfolio in Japanese assets.

Examples from Rakuten Securities

Screenshot of the mutual fund screener on Rakuten Securities' website.
This is the result of searching for ‘no load’ funds.

You can further narrow things down by choosing options on the left-hand column:

Screenshot of the mutual fund screener on Rakuten Securities' website, showing the result of selecting 'index based', 'foreign equities', and 'emerging markets'.
This is the result of selecting ‘index based’, ‘foreign equities’, and ’emerging markets’.

You can check the annual fees by selecting the second column (手数料等) and then sort from lowest to highest using the arrows. These are the three cheapest emerging market equity funds on Rakuten, all charging about 0.2% a year in fees with no purchase or redemption fees.

Mutual funds are available in taxable, iDeCo, and NISA accounts. They are the only option in iDeCo and Tsumitate NISA accounts.

Most people should be able to use mutual funds to make simple, low-cost portfolios for themselves. Invest regularly over the long term and you should do pretty well for yourself.

Glossary

FAQ

What is a mutual fund?

A mutual fund (投資信託 toushi shintaku in Japanese) is a popular investment option that allows individuals to pool their funds and invest in a diversified portfolio of stocks, bonds, or other securities. These funds are managed by professionals with expertise in investment management.

What are the advantages of mutual funds in Japan?

Mutual funds in Japan have several advantages, including low fees, ease of access, no additional charges for buying or selling shares, and relatively low annual costs. They can be purchased in Japanese yen, at any time, and investors have the flexibility to choose between receiving dividends or reinvesting them.

How does buying mutual funds in Japan compare to buying US ETFs?

Buying US ETFs involves additional steps such as currency conversion from yen to US dollars, potential fees associated with ETF purchases, US withholding taxes on dividend payments, and currency conversion back to yen when selling. In contrast, buying mutual funds in Japan eliminates these extra procedures.

What types of mutual funds are available in Japan?

Japan offers a diverse range of mutual funds that cater to various investment needs. These include no-load funds, index-based funds with attractive annual costs, and options focusing on different markets such as global equities, Japanese bonds, developed world equities, emerging market bonds, and more.

Where can I buy mutual funds in Japan?

You can purchase mutual funds in Japan through reputable trading platforms such as Rakuten Securities (楽天証券), SBI (SBI証券) and Monex (マネックス証券). These platforms offer a wide selection of mutual funds, making it convenient for you to explore and choose suitable investment options.


How about you? Are you investing in mutual funds? Anything to add? Share your experience or ask questions in the RetireJapan Forum.

11 Responses

  1. Nice article.
    One important point to add is that if you care about hidden costs, look into the funds to check if they invest directly in the underlying stocks, or if they just buy an ETF and resell it. Two of the cheapest funds in that last screenshot (SBI and Rakuten楽天) are just reselling an ETF that you can buy yourself, with added fees on top. Granted it does make it more convenient (as you said, no need to convert to USD and can buy in 1 yen denominations), but you will pay for the privilege. It’s probably better to buy a fund that actually buys the underlying stocks, rather than one that just buys a fund somebody else made and adds their fee on top.

    1. nice point! this question might sound silly, but how could I check whether they buy the underlying stocks or not? Thanks in advance

    2. Good point, adamu
      It seems the SBI fund adds a 0.06% fee onto the 0.13% fee on the underlying Schwab fund (SCHE) which does not appear to be available on Rakuten or SBI (Monex do have it).
      I think for a lot of people the convenience and fees will outweight the extra 0.06% fee.

      1. The SBI fund is actually a mix of three Schwab ETFs that anybody can buy. The Rakuten one is a wrapper of VT.
        There are also additional tax costs with these wrapper funds, as witholding tax is applied three times (country of origin, US on the whole fund, and Japan on the whole fund). A domestic fund can skip the US part, which is 10% of dividends.
        All the gory details are buried in this forum thread: https://www.retirejapan.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=184&start=50#p2273
        Another relevant thread where I try to summarise good options for getting a balanced portfolio while avoiding the ETF wrapper funds: https://www.retirejapan.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=310
        @OFFI the only way I know is to download and read the prospectus (in Japanese…)

  2. Like RetireJapan (and probably others here) I have also decided to switch from buying Japanese ETFs (1550 etc.) to mutual funds. A decision largely based on some of the recent forum threads about mutual funds (many thanks to the members who did all the research calculations for those).
    I just recently made my first mutual funds purchase (for my daughter’s JR NISA), and one thing that kind of surprised/confused me was the length of time it takes to process the purchase compared to ETFs.
    I put in an order on the 19th of this month for two eMAXIS Slim funds, 国内株式(TOPIX) and 全世界株式(除く日本). The trade dates (約定日) were 19th and the 22nd, and the delivery dates (受渡日) were the 24th and the 26th.
    So that means that in the case of the 全世界 fund, it took a full week to make the purchase. Is that just the way it is with mutual funds?

  3. You compared the advantages of a Japan Mutual Fund vs a US ETF, but about a comparison between a Japanese Mutual Fund and a Japanese ETF, what are the advantages if any?

    1. That’s a great question.
      In terms of costs, I found the following:
      Japan TOPIX ETF, annual cost 0.06%: https://www.blackrock.com/jp/individual/ja/products/279438/
      Japan TOPIX MF, annual cost 0.159%: https://emaxis.jp/lp/slim/index.html
      World developed equity ETF, annual cost 0.19%: https://www.blackrock.com/jp/individual/ja/products/290501/ishares-core-msci-kokusai-etf-fund
      World developed equity MF, annual cost 0.109%: https://emaxis.jp/lp/slim/index.html
      World emerging equities ETF, annual cost 0.23%: https://www.blackrock.com/jp/individual/ja/products/290503/ishares-core-msci-emerging-markets-imi-etf-fund
      World emerging equities MF, annual cost 0.189%: https://emaxis.jp/lp/slim/index.html
      There may be cheaper products, but this should give us a rough idea.
      Costs are roughly similar, with the mutual funds being slightly cheaper. ETFs may incur purchase fees, but the fees on domestic equities (which Japan-listed ETFs are) are pretty low.
      Mutual funds allow people to reinvest dividends automatically and arrange regular purchases.
      I’d say the mutual funds have a slight edge, but you could go with whichever you preferred and it wouldn’t be crazy 🙂

    2. we’ve done some deeper digs into this on the forum but the short version:
      the admin costs of the etfs can be slightly lower, but you pay trading costs on them and there are risks associated to speculation(since an ETF is valued by what people offer for it, not the net asset value)
      competition is strong among funds, but not really for etfs
      finally, many of the indexed mutual funds also reinvest dividends internally, allowing you to defer taxes.
      Overall, for long term holding funds are going to be better. If you’re speculating(something I personally would not recommend) ETF’s have the advantage of being possible to move immediately

  4. In a vacuum, ETFs are preferable to mutual funds (lower fees and taxes). Not all ETFs of course (and liquidity can be an issue for some ETFs) but as a general rule, you should need a reason to choose a mutual fund instead of an ETF if both offer similar exposure to the asset class you’re looking at.
    ETFs almost always have *lower* total fees, not higher. Read the fine print.

    1. Hi DA
      Very interesting. If you get a chance, could you explain any higher costs for the example below (feel free to use a cheaper ETF if you know of one):
      World developed equity ETF, annual cost 0.19%: https://www.blackrock.com/jp/individual/ja/products/290501/ishares-core-msci-kokusai-etf-fund
      World developed equity MF, annual cost 0.109%: https://emaxis.jp/lp/slim/index.html
      I think it would be really useful for the community to see where the hidden costs might be.